/assets/images/provider/photos/2867897.jpg)
Knee arthritis doesn’t have to mean giving up hiking, biking, skiing, working out—or simply moving through your day without thinking about your knees. When rest, over-the-counter medications and other conservative treatments are no longer enough, knee injections may offer another option before considering joint replacement surgery. Dr. Kevin O’Donnell explains the differences between cortisone, knee gel injections, PRP and prolotherapy, how he determines which treatment may be appropriate, and why treating knee arthritis is about more than temporary pain relief—it’s about keeping you active, strong and independent.
- Typically, if you’re having knee pain, you want to treat it conservatively at first with gentle but progressive motion, relative rest from offending activities, ice, and over-the-counter analgesics or anti-inflammatories. If you do that for a few weeks and it gets better , then I’m probably not needed. It’s really when your lifestyle starts being impacted—whether that’s exercise, walking, going up and down stairs, getting in and out of a chair—and the self-care isn’t working to your satisfaction.
One big thing that’s a negative predictor for something simple going on is if you’re limping. If you’re limping, you should probably see somebody and get it fully evaluated. The same goes if you have significant swelling. You can try self-care for a few days, but if the limping continues or your everyday life and activity are being impacted on a routine or prolonged basis , it’s time to have it evaluated.
History really tells you. If somebody had an acute twisting injury or sudden pain in their knee, that can be more indicative of something internally going on, such as a meniscus tear or, God forbid, an ACL tear. If there’s trauma or a twisting injury and you feel a pop or something instantaneous, that’s more aligned with having some type of tear in the knee.
With arthritis, it tends to be a slower progression with some layers in between. People with knee arthritis will typically get achiness after long walks or exercise, but also can have acute flares. Maybe they did 20,000 steps over the weekend and their knee swells, but there was no trauma or obvious injury. That’s more aligned with arthritis. Typically, we’re going to see knee arthritis in people between about 45 and 90 years old. If there’s no identifiable trauma and no specific injury the patient can identify, quite often we’re dealing with arthritis. Arthritis is exceedingly common.
If home care doesn’t work, a lot of people go see an orthopedist. They’ll typically evaluate the knee and usually get X-rays. You can diagnose arthritis clinically on an exam because people tend to hurt in the typical spots, but an X-ray or advanced imaging can show it more clearly.
The typical orthopedic route is to try physical therapy, which I recommend to everyone as well. A lot of orthopedic surgeons will recommend a corticosteroid injection, which is a potent anti-inflammatory and it works. The problem is that corticosteroid injections are usually a temporary fix. Corticosteroid or steroid shots help with symptom control, but they don’t do anything positive to address the underlying disease process. In fact, studies have shown that corticosteroid injections, particularly repeated ones, can lead to progression of arthritis.
Your typical patient may get about six to eight weeks of relief from a corticosteroid injection, and then they start the pain and swelling cycle all over again. The traditional approach can become, “Keep coming back for cortisone until it stops working, and then we’ll replace your knee.” We go in a different direction.
What we like to do is actually affect the underlying process of arthritis, which involves inflammation. With arthritis, you get a flooding of the joint with chemicals called cytokines that are pro-inflammatory. We don’t completely understand why somebody goes from having a normal knee to entering this phase. There are risk factors—older age, obesity, family history and a history of trauma—but once arthritis sets in, you’re not curing it.
The way I explain it to patients is that steroids are like taking a fire extinguisher to those pro-inflammatory chemicals residing in your knee. It calms them down for a while, but eventually that fire starts to smolder again and you repeat the cycle.
When we use biologics, what we’re trying to do is reverse or “reboot,” i, the internal environment of the joint. We can drain the inflammatory fluid out of the knee and then put positive, factors into the joint that are not destructive—they’re pro-growth. The goal is to change the environment of the knee back toward a healthier state.
Of anything that you can inject into an arthritic knee, platelet-rich plasma, or PRP, has shown significant benefit compared with other injectables, including steroids, stem cells and hyaluronic acid. PRP works very well for addressing that underlying process, which can help slow the progression of arthritis while also providing pain relief.
Typically, with a PRP injection or PRP series of injections, I’m looking for about one to two years of relief versus roughly six to eight weeks with a corticosteroid. But we still need physical therapy, strong quads, regular activity and weight management when appropriate. It’s all part of a plan for the patient, not just an injection. We will also recommend arthritis supplements that can help mitigate some of the symptoms people are experiencing.
When I do a PRP injection, I’m typically going to get an MRI of the knee to really gauge the severity of the arthritis and see whether there are additional or confounding injuries. A lot of times, people will also have degenerative meniscal pathology where the meniscus is beginning to wear away.
When we do a PRP injection, I’m not necessarily only injecting the joint. I’m looking at every other structure that may be damaged or loose. A lot of times when people lose joint space, the ligaments around the knee can become loose, so we’ll address that as well. The idea is to reverse that underlying inflammatory process while also addressing the structural issues related to it.
Knee gel injections are hyaluronic acid, which can come from natural or synthetic sources. Hyaluronic acid has shown a modest benefit for knee arthritis. Your body naturally produces hyaluronic acid to help lubricate tissues and allow joints to move. What we’ve found is that people with knee arthritis tend to have reduced natural levels of hyaluronic acid in the joint.
So somebody came up with the idea 30 or 40 years ago: What if we replace it, almost like an oil change? Adding hyaluronic acid can provide lubrication, and it can help a lot of patients.
If you compare PRP versus hyaluronic acid, studies have generally shown PRP to be superior. But I don’t forget about hyaluronic acid. Typically, if I’m treating knee arthritis, I willmay combine the two. I’m giving the pro-growth factors with PRP as well as hyaluronic acid for lubrication. Studies have shown that using the two together can be better than either one alone.
Prolotherapy can work very well for knee arthritis. For more mild arthritis, I might choose prolotherapy as a treatment path. The issue with prolotherapy is that it’s very gradual. Typically, to get a sustained response that the patient is happy with, you may be looking at three to six injections over time. Prolotherapy is more of a slow burn, but it can work very well.
If somebody has more than very mild arthritis, I’m typically going to jump to PRP because it’s usually one or two injections, which can be roughly equivalent to about three to six prolotherapy injections. Number one, it’s a more efficient way of doing it. Number two, it can work out to be about the same cost. So I rarely treat someone’s knee arthritis completely or exclusively with prolotherapy unless they’ve had it before and specifically request it. Typically, I’m going to go to PRP for knee arthritis.
Absolutely! Years ago, arthritis was often viewed as just part of getting older. You get arthritis, you sit on the porch with a glass of iced tea or sit on the couch, your knee hurts and you take aspirin. That doesn’t have to be the mindset anymore.
The good news is we live in Colorado, and the people who seek me out are usually pretty active—or at least weekend warriors. My goal is to get them back to whatever activity they’d like to accomplish, even at an older age.
One of the biggest problems as we age is muscle wasting over time. You become weaker, you lose muscle mass and eventually that affects your independence. We want to keep that muscle mass up, and in order to do that, you need your joints working at their highest possible level.
A good test is to sit on the floor with your legs crossed and see if you can stand up without using your arms or leaning onto one knee. Maintaining that kind of strength and mobility matters. Yes, I want to help with somebody’s knee pain, but I also want to keep them moving, active and strong into later life. That’s the bigger goal.
If knee pain is limiting your activity, changing the way you move or keeping you from doing the things you enjoy, it may be time to take a closer look at what’s actually happening inside the joint. At Revitalize Regenerative Orthopedics, Dr. Kevin O’Donnell evaluates both the underlying arthritis and the surrounding structures to develop an individualized, nonsurgical treatment plan focused on improving function and keeping you active. Book an assessment with Dr. O’Donnell to learn which knee injection options may be right for you.